LEDs or incandescent lamps: which is better?

Operating principle and design of LEDs and incandescent lamps

Light emitting diodes (LEDs) and incandescent light bulbs use different physical principles to create light. Incandescent light bulbs work by heating a thin tungsten filament, which emits light at a high temperature. This process is extremely energy-intensive and is accompanied by large heat losses: about 90% of the energy consumed is spent on heat, and only 10% is converted into light. LEDs, on the other hand, are based on the properties of semiconductors that, when current is passed through, emit light through electroluminescence. This process minimizes heat generation, making LEDs more efficient.

The design of incandescent lamps is extremely simple: a glass bulb filled with vacuum or inert gas, and a thin tungsten filament inside. This design makes them cheap, but fragile and short-lived. LEDs have a more complex design. In addition to the semiconductor element itself, they include a driver to stabilize the electrical current, a heat sink to dissipate heat, and an optical lens to distribute light. This ensures their high reliability and allows them to be used in various conditions – from home lighting to industrial lighting.

Energy consumption and efficiency

Incandescent light bulbs are among the most inefficient light sources. To produce a brightness equivalent to 800 lumens (roughly the light of a regular lamp), they require 60 watts of power. While an LED will only need 8-10 W to achieve the same brightness. This is due to the fact that LEDs convert up to 90% of the energy into light, while incandescent lamps lose it as heat.

The effectiveness of LEDs is especially noticeable with prolonged use. For example, in street lamps or offices where lighting is on for 8–12 hours a day, LEDs significantly reduce energy costs. Additionally, their low heat output makes them safe to install in enclosed spaces where overheating may be an issue. Thus, the choice of LEDs allows you to significantly save on electricity, which is especially important on the scale of enterprises and cities.

Durability and reliability

Incandescent lamps have an extremely limited service life – on average about 1000 hours. This is due to the gradual evaporation of tungsten from the filament, which over time leads to its thinning and burnout. LEDs can last from 25,000 to 50,000 hours, and sometimes longer, depending on the quality and operating conditions. They do not fail suddenly: over time, their brightness simply decreases, allowing replacement to be planned in advance.

LEDs are also highly reliable. Unlike fragile glass incandescent lamps, which are easily broken, LEDs are protected by durable housings made of plastic or aluminum. They are resistant to vibrations, shocks and temperature changes. This makes them an ideal solution for use in difficult environments, such as transport, industrial areas or on the streets, where equipment is exposed to external factors.

The quality of the world and the influence of vision

Incandescent lamps emit light with a continuous spectrum and a warm color temperature (about 2700 K), which is traditionally considered comfortable for the human eye. However, such lamps may flicker due to voltage instability, which is invisible to the eye, but can cause fatigue and headaches if exposed for long periods of time. LEDs do not have this drawback: they emit stable light if they are equipped with a high-quality driver that eliminates flicker.

Modern LEDs are capable of producing a wide range of color temperatures, from warm yellow to cool white light. Their color rendering index (CRI) can reach 90–95, allowing colors to be displayed close to their natural appearance. This is especially important in areas such as lighting of offices, schools and healthcare facilities, where the quality of light affects comfort and performance. In addition, LEDs can be customized to create a cozy atmosphere in living spaces.

Environmental friendliness and recycling

From an environmental point of view, incandescent lamps leave an undesirable footprint. Their low energy efficiency increases electricity consumption, which in turn increases carbon emissions. In addition, the materials used in such lamps are difficult to recycle, making their disposal problematic. These factors make them a poor choice for the environment.

LEDs, on the other hand, are considered an environmentally friendly solution. They do not contain toxic substances such as mercury, which is present, for example, in fluorescent lamps. Due to their longevity, LEDs require less frequent replacement, reducing waste. In addition, they significantly reduce energy costs, which has a positive effect on the environmental balance. LEDs are also easier to recycle, making them a preferred option for those who are environmentally conscious.

Cost and economic benefit

Lighting is one of the significant expense items in both domestic and commercial areas. The choice between incandescent and LED lamps has a significant impact on energy costs, maintenance and replacement of lighting fixturesditch Economic benefit depends on a number of factors, including initial cost, duration of use and effectiveness.

1. Initial cost. LEDs are more expensive to purchase than incandescent bulbs. However, their high cost is compensated during operation by reducing energy costs.
2. Durability. LEDs last up to 50 times longer than incandescent bulbs, reducing the frequency of replacements and the cost of purchasing new bulbs.
3. Energy efficiency. Over a year of operation, LEDs can save up to 80% of energy compared to incandescent lamps, which significantly reduces electricity bills.
4. Maintenance costs. Due to their longevity, LEDs require minimal maintenance and require replacement less often, which is especially important for commercial and industrial applications.
5. Payback. Despite the high initial cost, LEDs pay for themselves within a few months due to their energy efficiency and durability.

Therefore, LEDs provide a cost-effective solution for long-term use. They reduce energy and maintenance costs, which is especially important for large enterprises and facilities with 24-hour lighting. Their installation is becoming increasingly popular not only because of the technological advantages, but also because of the real savings.

Questions and answers